Saturday, April 11, 2020

When AbuBakr's daughter used to Mut’ah!

The daughter of Abu Bakr, Aisha's sister, used to Mut'ah (Temporary Marriage) according to a Sahih document from authentic Sunni books


 Abu Ja'far Tahawi, a well-known Sunni scholar, writes:

Saeed bin Jubayr says: I heard from Abdullah ibn Zubayr while he was giving a speech in which he was mocking Ibn 'Abbas and objecting his opinion about Mut’ah.
Ibn Abbas said: 'If he is telling the truth, then he must  ask his mother!!!'  He asked his mother. His mother (Asmaa, Abu Bakr's daughter) said: 'Ibn Abbas is right, it is so!' ” [1]

This narration is authentic considering the source and also according to the principles of the Rijal science of Ahlus Sunnah, and no objection can be entered for it.


 In the lectures of Al-Adba, Ragheb vol. 2, P.23, chapter, Permission on Mut'ah:

Ibn Zubayr said to Ibn Abbas:
Why do you give a fatwa that Mut'ah is permissible? He replied, "Ask your mother how she conceived you." So he asked, "She replied, 'I gave birth to you through Mut'ah.' [2]


Muslim Qarayi says:

We went to Asmaa, the daughter of Abu Bakr (mother of Abdullah Ibn Zubayr) and asked her about the Mut'ah, and she replied: 'We did this during the time of the Messenger of God' (may God bless him and grant him peace)!! [3]

This narration indicates that Abu Bakr's eldest daughter was one of those who believed in temporary marriage (Mut'ah)  and she did it herself. The source of this narration is also 100% authentic according to the Sunni basis:


Sources:
.1.  Sharh Maani al-Asar Vol.3 ,P.24
 شرح معانی الاثار ج۳ص۲۴

2. The same content is briefly mentioned in the following books:

Zaadul Ma'aad Vol.2, P206
 زاد المعاد ج 2 ص 206
 Al-Tamheed Laban Abd Al-Barr vol. 8 p. 208
التمهيد لابن عبد البر ج8 ص 208
 Ibn Abd al-Barr, vol. 4, p. 61
 الاستذكار ابن عبد البر ج4 ص61

3. Al-Nisa'i, Al-Sunan Al-Kubra, vol. 3, p. 326
  النسائي، السنن الكبرى، ج3، ص326


_____

 Shia Asks: In the end, Mut'ah Halal or Haram?

 If haram, => it is Zina =>  Sister of Ayisha  commited Zina => The Caliph (R.A) did not punish her according Quran❗️{then really R.A ????!}

If Halal, then Umar (R.A) is a liar and innovator in the religion.
{Again R.A ???!!!!!!!!!!!!}

 This is absolutely an insult to Allah (Subhana wa Ta'ala) to ask his blessing on someone who has changed the religion and made innovation in the Sunnah of Messenger of Allah

 Insulting Allah is Shirk!!!

.....And Allah never forgives shirk...

Now you are  free to use  R.A for him as much as you want 🙃

____
We beg you THINK then choose sunnism.

No comments:

Post a Comment